RegvaJournal

Volume 1, reported since May 2026. SEC rulemaking, litigation and enforcement analysis.

Regva Journal / Rulemaking

RulemakingPress Release 2026-85Proposed rule

SEC Rulemaking Targets Adviser Pay-to-Play Rule for Rescission

On Sept. 3, 2026, the SEC proposed rescinding Rule 206(4)-5, the 2010 adviser pay-to-play rule. What this SEC rulemaking would change and who it would affect.

Sep 3, 20263 min read

Headnotes

  1. The proposal would eliminate Rule 206(4)-5 in full.
  2. The rule was adopted in 2010. The SEC now says experience over more than 15 years has revealed significant unintended consequences.
  3. The SEC’s criticism of strict liability goes to how the rule operates.

WASHINGTON — The Securities and Exchange Commission on September 3, 2026 opened an SEC rulemaking to rescind the investment adviser pay-to-play rule, a 15-year-old restriction that has shaped how money managers and their employees approach political giving to state and local officials.

The rule at issue, Advisers Act Rule 206(4)-5, bars an investment adviser from receiving compensation for advisory services to a government client for two years after the adviser or certain of its employees makes a political contribution to an elected official or candidate who can influence the selection of advisers.

What the proposal would do

The proposal would eliminate Rule 206(4)-5 in full. It would also amend the Advisers Act recordkeeping rule to remove the provisions that require advisers to keep records tied to political contributions, which exist only to support the pay-to-play rule.

The agency stressed what would not change. Advisers would remain subject to the Advisers Act’s anti-fraud prohibitions, their fiduciary duty to clients, the compliance program rule and code of ethics requirements. In the SEC’s framing, those broader obligations would continue to govern how advisers win and serve government business.

The agency’s case

The rule was adopted in 2010. The SEC now says experience over more than 15 years has revealed significant unintended consequences.

It cites three. Implementation has proven operationally difficult, requiring firms to track employees’ political activity closely. The rule chills political speech. And its strict-liability design means even small contributions can trigger a two-year compensation ban, regardless of whether there was any intent to influence an award.

Chairman Paul S. Atkins said the rule “is overly prescriptive” and has produced unintended consequences. He argued that political contribution matters belong to local ordinances, state laws and federal election regulation rather than the SEC.

The strict-liability problem

The SEC’s criticism of strict liability goes to how the rule operates. Under the current framework, a covered contribution triggers the two-year time-out regardless of whether anyone intended to influence a hiring decision, subject to limited exceptions and de minimis allowances. The agency now argues that this design punishes small, innocent donations and imposes compliance burdens out of proportion to the risk it addresses.

Who would be affected

Investment advisers that manage public pension assets, state college savings plans and other government funds are the most directly affected. Many have built compliance programs around preclearance of employee contributions and look-back reviews for new hires; rescission would remove the federal basis for those controls, though firms could keep them voluntarily.

Public pension systems and their trustees would also feel the change. Some states and municipalities have their own pay-to-play laws or procurement rules, and the SEC’s framing anticipates that those regimes would fill the gap. Where no local rule exists, oversight would rest on general fiduciary and anti-fraud standards.

The proposal also has implications for related regimes. Self-regulatory organizations have adopted pay-to-play rules for broker-dealers and municipal advisors that were designed to work alongside the SEC’s adviser rule, and market participants will look for signals about whether those rules are revisited.

For compliance departments, the immediate question is not whether to stop monitoring but when. Until a final rule is adopted and takes effect, Rule 206(4)-5 remains in force, and contributions made in the interim could still trigger the two-year compensation ban.

What to watch

The public comment period runs 60 days after publication in the Federal Register. Key issues include whether public pension officials and state regulators support or oppose the change, whether any commissioner dissents, and whether the agency coordinates with self-regulatory organizations on parallel rules. Advisers should also watch the effective date of any final rescission before dismantling contribution monitoring.

Prepared with AI assistance from the releases cited in the margin and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not legal advice.